Hm, well I guess I don't actually know whether I'm in or out of the broom closet. I haven't made any big announcement to anyone and I don't advertise my beliefs, but then I never did, even when I was a pretty traditional Christian.
I guess my neighbors might have wondered what's up with the fires and flute playing late at night on the full moon but none of them have asked nor have they treated me any differently so they apparently don't think I'm doing anything dangerous, anyway! I suppose they think it's an Indian thing. (That's definitely one nice thing about having American Indian background - when you practice magick everyone thinks it's part of your traditional heritage whether it is or not!

)
My friends know I quit the church and they have observed that I'm really a lot happier. While I sometimes talk about some of my activities (meditation, herbalism) I don't call it witchcraft and I think they just think I'm a little eccentric - something they already knew! I don't pursue friendships with rigid, intolerant people so I doubt any of them would be tremendously distressed if I did admit to being a witch.
My daughter knows, of course, and we compare notes on meditation, rituals, etc., but I'm actually the one who chose this path first. I'm not in real close contact with the rest of my family; I'm an only child and my parents are dead so I only have extended family anyway. And of course I now have some new friends who I met BECAUSE I'm pagan and who are pagan as well. In these parts, most adult pagans keep a fairly low profile just because we're in such a minority, but I don't think that's the same as being fully closeted.
I guess I just can't gauge how far out of the closet I might be since I've always been a private person and I've always had a manner which discourages prying questions.